Subreddits like r/buttsharpies

region: plugged · insertions · loose

Welcome to r/buttsharpies, home of the infamous "sharpie in pooper" craze. Please remember that all submissions are submitted by dudes…

1,055 distinct commenters from Oct 2025 to Sep 2026 · 186,413 subscribers

Similarity is measured by shared commenters, not by text: these are the communities whose commenters overlapped most with r/buttsharpies's from Oct 2025 to Sep 2026.

• r/sharpiechallange
  sharpiechallange for all your competitive sharpie stuffing needs.
• r/insertions
  Girls inserting objects into holes.
• r/kinky_insertions
• r/notadildo
  Anything is a dildo if you're brave enough 😉. That old dildo or vibrator not doing it for you anymore? Maybe it's time to venture into…
• r/foodandobjects
  Ive Noticed There Is No Specific Stuff For Food And Object Insertions Anymore. so please post here
• r/pushing
  This subreddit is a collection of original clips and videos. Ever seen a stripper shoot a ping pong ball out of her pussy? It's like…
• r/things_in_pussies
  What things can you put in your pussy and vids/pics of them coming out? Don't forget to add flair for fun. 😜
• r/insertions_nsfw
  People using everday objects as sex toys. Pens, bats, bed posts and anything else you want to use.

18+. From the Subreddit Atlas, a map of NSFW Reddit communities built from archived metadata: author names, subreddit names, and counts only, no post content. Methodology & removal requests · all subreddits