Subreddits similar to r/buttsharpies

region: anal · buttsharpies · dildo

Welcome to r/buttsharpies, home of the infamous "sharpie in pooper" craze. Please remember that all submissions are submitted by dudes…

1,444 distinct commenters in 2025 · 186,413 subscribers

Similarity is measured by shared commenters, not by text: these are the communities whose 2025 commenters overlapped most with r/buttsharpies's.

• r/insertions
  Girls inserting objects into holes.
• r/notadildo
  Anything is a dildo if you're brave enough 😉. That old dildo or vibrator not doing it for you anymore? Maybe it's time to venture into…
• r/pumpedpussy
  This subreddit was created for the men and women who enjoy the voluptuous aesthetics of a vagina that has been vacuum-pumped.
• r/extremefetishes
  BDSM taken to the next level. we want to see pictures, artwork, and story's of your most depraved fetishes and fantasy's. If you're not…
• r/alteredbuttholes
  Tight buttholes are not welcome. This sub is dedicated to the ragged, blown out, prolapsed, destroyed, and/or generally ruined asshole. If…
• r/fisting
  A sub-reddit for sharing Fisting-fetish pics, gifs, videos, etc. and discussion.
• r/tittorture
  Videos, pictures, or gifs of tits in pain
• r/highmileageholes
  Holes that have seen things, things you wouldn't believe... A subreddit for women that are visibly very experienced.

18+. From the Subreddit Atlas, a map of NSFW Reddit communities built from archived metadata: author names, subreddit names, and counts only, no post content. Methodology & removal requests · all subreddits